Clear, Thin, and Effective: Choosing Between Plastic Retainers and Invisalign
Oral Health Blog

Clear, Thin, and Effective: Choosing Between Plastic Retainers and Invisalign


When deciding between plastic retainers and Invisalign, hygiene is paramount. Using a purple persulfate-free retainer cleaner ensures cleanliness for both options. This cleaner helps maintain the effectiveness of plastic retainers and Invisalign aligners, ensuring optimal oral hygiene and treatment outcomes.

In this article, we'll explore the thickness factor and help you understand the distinctions between these two orthodontic appliances.

1. Plastic Retainers: A Closer Look

  • Material: Plastic retainers, also known as clear plastic or Essix retainers, are made from a transparent, durable plastic material.
  • Design: They closely resemble Invisalign aligners in design, covering your teeth entirely.
  • Thickness: Plastic retainers are generally thicker than Invisalign aligners.

2. Invisalign Aligners: A Closer Look

  • Material: Invisalign aligners are crafted from a patented thermoplastic material called SmartTrack.
  • Design: Invisalign aligners are a set of clear, custom-made aligners used for orthodontic treatment. They are designed to exert pressure on your teeth and gradually move them into their correct positions.
  • Thickness: Invisalign aligners are relatively thinner compared to plastic retainers.

3. The Thickness Comparison

When discussing thickness, it's essential to note that there can be variation in the thickness of plastic retainers and Invisalign aligners. Both are custom-made to fit your teeth perfectly, but some factors can influence their thickness:

  • Individual Needs: The amount of correction needed, the shape of your teeth, and your orthodontic treatment history can influence the thickness of both plastic retainers and Invisalign aligners.

  • Phase of Treatment: Invisalign aligners tend to vary in thickness during different phases of orthodontic treatment. Aligners used in the initial stages of treatment might be thicker to apply more significant force for teeth movement.

  • Comfort and Effectiveness: Orthodontists aim to balance thickness for effectiveness and comfort. They ensure that your plastic retainers or Invisalign aligners are thick enough to be effective but not so thick as to cause discomfort.

4. Practical Implications of Thickness

  • Plastic Retainers: The slightly thicker design of plastic retainers can make them more durable and suitable for long-term retention. They are excellent for holding your teeth in place after orthodontic treatment.

  • Invisalign Aligners: Invisalign aligners, while thinner, are highly effective for orthodontic treatment. Their thinner profile often means a more comfortable fit and less noticeable appearance during treatment.

5. Choosing Between Plastic Retainers and Invisalign

Choosing between plastic retainers and Invisalign depends on your specific needs:

  • Post-Treatment Retention: If you've completed orthodontic treatment and want to maintain your newly aligned teeth, plastic retainers might be an excellent choice due to their thickness and durability.

  • Orthodontic Correction: If you require orthodontic correction and desire a discreet, thin option, Invisalign aligners could be more suitable for your needs.

6. Consult with Your Orthodontist

Ultimately, the decision should be made in consultation with your orthodontist. They will assess your dental condition, treatment goals, and lifestyle to recommend the most appropriate option. Your orthodontist will ensure that your chosen appliance is custom-made to fit your teeth comfortably and effectively.


In the thickness showdown between plastic retainers and Invisalign aligners, the winner depends on your specific orthodontic needs and goals. While plastic retainers are generally thicker and more suitable for long-term retention, Invisalign aligners offer a thinner, discreet alternative for orthodontic correction. Consulting with your orthodontist is the best approach to choosing the right option for your smile journey. The good news is that both options are custom-made for your comfort and effectiveness, ensuring a beautiful smile at the end of your orthodontic adventure.

Are you currently using or thinking about using retainer cleaning tablets? It's important to be aware that certain cleaner brands have the potential to cause toxic reactions.

It's crucial to be aware of harmful ingredients hiding in common cleaner brands. One such persulfate, which can pose SERIOUS health risks and is found in almost all leading retainer cleaners brands. Moreover, persulfate's health risks potentially impact respiratory health and skin sensitivities in your family, especially in teens and sensitive individuals. Learn more about the risk of persulfate HERE.



The content in this article is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice. Always consult with a healthcare provider before making any changes to your health regimen. The author and publisher do not take responsibility for any consequences resulting from the information provided in this article.